Farmers Rain on Monsanto's Parade

Farmers Rain on Monsanto's Parade
Published: Jun 28, 2020
A crisis facing Mexican corn farmers emerged decades ago as corporate giant Monsanto pushed to get the country to use its GMO corn seed. As a result, a movement was spawned to prevent industrial agriculture from threatening the sustainability of thousands of years of farming tradition. In February, we visited Oaxaca to report on an important meeting to address the crisis, and followed a troupe of artists who were hard at work on making some theatre art for the cause. ¶ Essay by Chris Lowry. Photographs by Whitney Smith. § An 18 minute read.

Mural by Rose Marial Garcia, journal of wild culture ©2020

Milagros de la Milpa” (Miracles of the Milpa, or traditional Mexican cornfield), a mural by Mariel Rose Garcia, was painted at the Posada del Marqués hotel during the week-long event — and earned a discount for the participants’ rooms.

We are in the cathedral plaza — also called the zócalo — the spiritual and recreational centre of the town and region of Oaxaca, Mexico. It is a magnet for families, hustlers, and gringo travellers. Small, stout ladies, nestled among their blowup animals and gaudy helium balloons, beckon passers-by to make a sale. Here around la catedral and the palm trees and gardens and low sheltered café terraces is the flow of conviviality and commerce. It is also a place for the renewal of bone-weary souls.

I came here twenty years ago when my two sons, 4 and 6, were drawn to it like excited bees to an exotic garden. But this trip is different. The kids are grown, pursuing their own trajectories, and I am here with my old friend and wild culturist, Whitney Smith. We know that later in the week there will be a street performance and a ceremonial procession, a spectacle with acrobats and a colloquium. We’re not sure what to expect, but we like it that way. The precious tolerance for ambiguity is a muscle that needs to be exercised.

He made a vow to light a ceremonial fire every day for a year.

The friend who invited us here is Chris Wells, a community animator, singer-songwriter, poet and farmer. He is known internationally for his work in the tradition of socio-political performance art with huge puppets. His organization, the All Species Project, is similar to many pageantry theatre companies around the world; a very short list would include Bread and Puppet Theatre in Vermont, Welfare State International in the UK, Shadowland Theatre in Toronto (co-founded by Whitney), and Wise Fool in New Mexico, whose co-founder, Amy Christian, has joined this week's event as a lead puppeteer.

These companies go into small communities and teach people how to make giant figures out of papier maché, how to walk and dance on stilts, how to play horns and drums — whatever is needed to tell brave stories through outdoor performance. With the All Species Project, Chris Wells has done that all his life. And here he is today in the mid-seventies, doing it again. He calls it 're-enchanting the world.'

The reason that Wells and his troupe have gathered here is to organize a full day of events called 'Milpa Mexico: Tradicion, Ciencia y Futuro' (Mexican Cornfield: Tradition, Science and Future). The purpose of it all is to promote the defence of traditional corn farming threatened by agriculture industrialization, a topic of great importance and urgency to the farmers in Oaxaca.


John McLeod, journal of wild culture, ©2020

Retired teacher and writer John McLeod becomes a man of the All Species cloth.


We join Chris and the members of his current tribe in the courtyard of their hotel. They have just finished a long day of work — building puppets, painting fabric and sewing costumes, honing logistics. The team are all artists and craftspeople and raconteurs of one kind or another, and they are clearly united in their passions. The inexpensive but commodious hotel, the Posada Marquez (the Marques being Cortez), is giving them rooms at a discounted rate, partly because a young painter from Santa Fé, New Mexico, Rose Mariel Garcia, is tasked with painting a mural of a lush cornfield on a wall beside by the pool.

As the guitars and Mezcal are passed around, songs in English and Spanish fill the air of the courtyard. José ‘Pepe’ Azcona is an elder Oaxacan artist who supervises the making of the larger-than-life figures for the procession. He focuses, delightedly, as we play some American standards by Gershwin and Porter. “No hablo ingles” he says. “Escucho con mi corazón.” (I don't speak English. I listen with my heart.)

A thoughtful and gentle young man in his thirties, Ibrahim, also from Santa Fe, is off in a corner practising the art of traditional fire-making, without matches. Recently he made a vow to light a ceremonial fire every day for a year.


All Species Oaxaca Feb15_20, journal of wild culture ©2020

Chris Wells and his star stilt dancer, Sabino, on their way to the desirous crowds waiting in the town square.


The night rolls on painlessly. Roasted tamales and fresh corn tortillas appear magically on the table beside the beer and small glasses of mezcal. Tracy Barnett, an American journalist living in Mexico whose website, The Esperanza Project, "gives voice to those who are building a better world", picks up a guitar and begins singing a haunting melody. It’s a ranchera ballad called ‘La Llorona’, the weeping woman, a dark folk tale full of vivid images. I resolve to learn it. While the song fills the air, Ibrahim comes forward to light a fire. Putting wood shavings into a stone bowl, he spins a piece of wooden dowel attached to a string. When the friction of the dowel gets hot enough, the shavings catch fire. He will do this again tomorrow evening in front of hundreds of people in the city's amphitheatre, following the procession through the streets.

I feel a bit like Spock among Earthlings, carrying my alien culture and political perspective from el norte with care and respect. Regardless of what your job is here, there is mutual recognition of a common cause: an ecological way of being. It intrigues and moves me that these people are expressing this shared vision by making things by hand and participating in a theatre for the citizens of the town without expectation of reward.

This is their way of defending the way of life of small farmers, and advocating for the protection of native corn from contamination by genetically modified varieties (GMOs). The story of corn is a very long one. The central valley of Oaxaca is one of the places that corn first flourished 6,000 years ago, carefully cultivated in a very selective way by Mesoamerican farmers from a grass called téosinte.


Giant puppets Oaxaca All Species Project, journal of wild culture ©2020

José ‘Pepe’ Azcona in the conical hat (foreground) between puppets and posters that read: Without Corn, There is No Peace . . . Defence of the Earth.


In the morning we attend a press conference to start off the day of events, which bears witness to a rare collaboration between campesino leaders and scholars. They share stories about the problems of local farmers, including corporate agrobusiness and their GMO seeds, unfair trade, rising land prices due to strangers looking for recreational properties in this beautiful place, and climate change. One of the local leaders in this struggle is Gustavo Esteva, a well-known Mexican activist and educator, a long time colleague of Ivan Illich. He speaks about Via Campesina, a coalition of small farmers in 120 countries, as the largest organization in all human history.

“Small farmers, mainly women,” says Esteva, “feed 70 percent of the world’s population today, while agri-businesses owning more than half of the planet’s food resources are only feeding 30 percent.” Esteva contends that “defending the native corn is a matter of life or death. To say that we are a people of corn is not a pretty metaphor, but rather, it is the state of things.”

The coordinator of the colloquium, Ana Ruiz, is a Mexican academic specializing in Physical Anthropology. She is one of the leaders of a team that launched a class action suit against Monsanto’s efforts to dominate global corn and grain production with genetically-modified seeds. The suit sought to ban transgenic corn in Mexico and in 2013 it was successful, a spectacular victory for farmers trying to maintain the viability ancient and indigenous strains of corn seeds.

The bird puppeteers get up on their stilts and start flexing and hopping — ‘getting their legs’.

Back at the Posada Marques, many hands put the finishing touches on giant puppets, banners and bird costumes for stilt dancers. A local parade band with plenty of brass and percussion, The Conquistadores, arrives and tries out a few raucous tunes on us. The sudden mayhem they create leads to some dancing. The bird puppeteers get up on their stilts and start flexing and hopping — ‘getting their legs’. Pepe is wearing a conical straw hat, anxious to get going. Wells sits atop his bicycle, calmly observing as the final puppet costume details are attended to. He will ride alongside the procession as supervisor, directing while he moves back and forth — keeping an out for anything that could interfere with the procession.

Not the largest but the most important puppets in this parade depict the activists Homero Gómez Gonzáles and Berta Caceres, recently assassinated in Mexico and Honduras. Homero was a former logger in the state of Michoacán and the director of El Rosario Monarch Butterfly Biosphere Reserve; he was killed for his opposition to illegal logging. Berta was internationally recognized for her work for environmental and social justice in Honduras. She led a year-long grassroots protest that prevented the building of a dam on the Rio Gualcarque. Berta was assassinated in her home at age 44.


Cheran! All Species, journal of wild cuture ©2020

"Women, concerned that a natural spring was being threatened by the logging, led the original actions. Politicians, police, cartel activities, and loggers were forced out of Cherán." — John McLeod. Puppets by Amy Christian.


Also in the parade are large puppet figures of indigenous farmers with clenched fists, under the word “Cherán!” While the deaths of Berta and Homero have been reported in the international media, I have never heard of Cherán, a community, also in Michoacán, that has taken its land and community back from corruption, cartels, politicians, and their former police force. 
As dusk falls, the parade moves out of the courtyard of the hotel and wends its way into the public sphere with volume and gusto. Through the narrow streets jammed with pedestrians who move gladly aside to watch, past sidewalk stalls and grand markets, around the gazebo in the central gardens of the zócalo, by the cathedral and down more cobbled streets. Some onlookers are curious yet puzzled, many are thrilled and proud that this happening in their city.


Ibrahim the Fire Jaguar, All Species Project, journal of wild culture ©2020

His daily ritual for one year . . . Ibrahim the Fire Jaguar unpacks his bag to quickly light a fire without matches or a lighter.


Forty minutes later the procession spills into the Plaza de la Danza, an outdoor theatre made entirely of stone. As an audience of a hundred people settles on the terraced stone steps, the Mermejita ‘bioloco’ circus — partners with Wells in this venture — sets up a huge tripod to support the acrobatic performance. Actors dressed as bats, bees, butterflies and wild felines, pollinating and controlling crop pests weave a fabulous dance into the web of life. The performance features a pantomime of Monsanto as a fat man with a sprayer threatening these creatures, melodramatic slapstick clowning that seemed to appeal to many, particularly children. The audience is clearly moved by the visual poetry of the caterpillar becoming the monarch butterfly woman.

Dressed as corn, gods, goddesses and wildlife, Wells and his friends celebrate the tattered web of life. They defy the crashing waves of corporate agriculture and the rising tide of late capitalism’s suicide economics. On his guitar, he has written a 21st century mutation of what Woody Guthrie had scrawled on his guitar: ‘This Machine Composts Fear’. (Guthrie’s read: ‘This Machine Kills Fascists’).

Later in the evening, after the puppets and dancing jaguars become people again, I help to sweep up the husks of the monarch chrysalis. Others roll up the banners that say “Justice for the Guardians of the Earth” and ‘Todos somos Berta’/‘We are all Berta.’ ≈ç


Mermejita All Species Oaxaca, journal of WIld CUlture ©2020

In Oaxaca's Plaza de la Danza . . . acrobats of the Mermejita Circus, partners with the All Species Project, performing for Homero and Berta.



§  'Protecting our Guardians in Oaxaca' by John McLeod >

§  'Milpa in Mexico: Defending a Way of Life' by Gustavo Esteva >

§  'Women of the South Against Masculine Assumptions' by Gustavo Esteva >

§  'GMO Corn, Mexico, and Coloniality' by Ernesto Hernandez Lopez >




Chris Wells and Pepe, journal of wild culture, Whitney Smith ©2020

When the show is done, Chris and Pepe, partners in glorious pageantry, hold each other upright.


WC para break


CHRIS LOWRY is a media producer and singer. Before working for many years in international development and sustainability, he made films on art and music, and is currently working on a documentary feature about the Canadian cultural figure Ross Woodman, Rebel Angel. Chris was part of the original team that created The Journal or Wild Culture with Whitney Smith in 1986, and served as the magazine’s Senior Editor. He lives in Toronto. View Chris' site.

WHITNEY SMITH is the founder and Publisher/Editor of The Journal of Wild Culture.





From Ana Ruiz:

It made me so happy to read again today this article.
I had been praying for artists to join us to defeat the transnationals, and in February they all took the message to the vanguard by addressing the assassination of forest and human rights guardians.
The incredible four-piece event, organized by All Species Project with Chris Wells and allies, still resonates with farmers and scholars who participated; its name, 'Maíz Mexico tradición ciencia ¿y futuro?' was the perfect crucible. I wish to maintain this name for the next event in 2021 or 2022.
Yes, our lawyers have managed to hold the court’s injunction that forbids to accept permits to plant GMO corn all over Mexico; yet, from an historic perspective, it holds as if hanging on a spiderweb.

Tue, 07/07/2020 - 05:09

Ken Lassman comment.

Many, many thanks for this, Chris! It's just another example of what you've been providing us for so many years. It just so happens that a short time ago I stumbled across the original Wild Culture book that you and Whitney put out in 1992, Specimens from the Journal of Wild Culture, and so I put it where I could read snippets all over again (the bathroom, of course) and it holds up very well indeed. Here are some examples:

— Gloria Steinem, Susan Brownmiller, Kennedy Fraser, Gael Love and other's discussion about the Psychology of Fashion, facilitated by Marilyn Powell is a well focused snapshop of insights that has continued to evolve in the fashion world ever since--it's fascinating to see what folks were thinking of then.

— Paul Shepard's interview about how sanity is based not only on good mother/familial attachment in early life but also on good connections to the more-than-human-world at that same time rings very true in our screen dominated world today.  

— Stephen Kline's Greening of Madison Avenue chronicles the early stages of what we call greenwashing today in a prophetic way.

— Michael Statlander and Chris Klugman's thoughts on locavore restaurants capture the beginnings of a movement that has since exploded.

—John Ferguson's musings in his Northern Lights speculations seems eerily innocent, predating the grid of GPS satellites and soon-to-be horrific cloud of 5G satellites that may ruin our views of the skies forever.

And on and on. It's a testament to your journalistic seining that these catches from 28 years ago still shimmer and jump like they were caught today.


Tue, 07/07/2020 - 05:12

Chris Wells in Oaxaca...

Thanks a mountain for this article Señor Lowry and Whitney of Wild Culture. You caught our magic like few have before. These events prepared over two years turned out to be a great Bioarchist, as contrasted with anarchist gatherings. It became another merging of the northern bioregionals with the southern Mexicans. It’s reverberating well in Oaxacan social weaving and serves as an ecological anchor in a sea of confusion during the V [COVID 19]. The Milpa and the Three Sisters Garden [corn, beans and squash] — including 90 wild greens and beehives — are the medicines for the relocalization of health and food and social systems.

Each moon now is a new world. This week on Tuesday [June 23], we survived a 7.5 earthquake and now 4 days of 5 and 6 aftershocks. The 60 families of my community are in shock and exhausted and, as good Oaxacans, trying to laugh more than cry. Local saying: 'only two things are guaranteed -- death and bad jokes.'

Miraculously I was offered a small plane ride to the city from my home on the coast just hours before the quake caved in my tile roof. Our farm team at home tell me the house structures survived without cracks. This is why Mexicans love cement and rebar so ardently. The landscape waved like a blanket being shaken clean by a god. In Oaxaca City, I was at the main Zocalo market outside as an ancient street of stone block rippled up like a dragon’s back and waved the whole street. I ran to the middle of the street as ancient facades of cement and plaster fell on the sidewalk.

I got an amazing new perspective on earthquakes from the air. It shook the high mountain ranges of coastal Oaxaca all the way through so that I still saw blocks falling from buildings on the other side of the massive mountains I had just flown over.


Tue, 07/07/2020 - 05:16

From Susan Meeker-Lowry in Delanson, NY:

How wonderful to see familiar faces, a few years older, still smiling, still doing such wonderful things! I absolutely love this.

In 2017, I floated the idea of using All Species pageantry street theater, when we were fighting Nestlé's plans to put a plastic water bottling plant in our little town. (Nestlé already "won" — after going to the supreme court — a 45 year contract to mine water from the aquifer under our town). I don't think people really got it. Some were familiar with Bread and Puppet, but I think they were intimidated a bit, and just not ready for being so "out there". Yet for me the fun, the costumes, the art/culture coupled with the anti-Nestlé, pro-water-is-life message would have strongly benefited from the community involvement that would have had to happen to pull something like this off.

Thanks so much for posting this here!



Tue, 07/07/2020 - 05:19

Add new comment